Maximize Your Retirement with Senior Financial Services Inc - Annuities in Retirement Planning Part 3 (FIA vs SPIA)
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
At Senior Financial Services we don’t take shortcuts. Hard work and research are hallmarks of our practice.
For help with your retirement planning needs, contact Fred Orentlich of Senior Financial Services at 800-679-2858
Maximize Your Retirement with SeniorFinancial Services Inc
Definitions
|
Term |
Meaning |
|
FIA (Fixed Indexed Annuity) |
A deferred annuity that grows based on the performance of a market index (like the S&P 500), with a guaranteed minimum interest rate. |
|
SPIA (Single Premium Immediate Annuity) |
An annuity purchased with a single lump sum that starts paying a guaranteed income immediately, typically for life or a fixed period. |
Key Features Comparison
|
Feature |
FIA |
SPIA |
|
Payment Start |
Deferred (months/years later) |
Immediate (usually within 1 month) |
|
Income |
Not guaranteed monthly until annuitized; growth depends on index |
Guaranteed monthly income immediately |
|
Market Exposure |
Linked to index performance (often capped or with participation rate) |
None; fixed payout |
|
Principal Protection |
Guaranteed minimum (usually 0–1%) |
Full principal “annuitized” into payments; not returned unless death benefit rider |
|
Tax Treatment |
Tax-deferred growth until withdrawal |
Portion of each payment is taxable as income; principal is return of investment |
|
Liquidity |
Limited; surrender charges apply |
None; payments cannot usually be withdrawn as lump sum |
|
Inflation Protection |
Optional rider (extra cost) |
Rarely adjustable; may include inflation rider at extra cost |
|
Purpose in Retirement |
Growth with some protection; optional future income |
Immediate income; replaces paycheck; hedges longevity risk |
Pros & Cons
FIA (Fixed Indexed Annuity)
Pros:
- Tax-deferred growth
- Participation in market gains without direct stock risk
- Minimum guaranteed interest protects principal
- Can add lifetime income rider later
Cons:
- Complex; returns limited by caps, spreads, or participation rates
- Early withdrawals trigger surrender charges
- Guaranteed income only if annuitized
SPIA (Single Premium Immediate Annuity)
Pros:
- Predictable lifetime income (like Social Security)
- Simple; easy to understand
- No market risk
- Immediate cash flow for retirement needs
Cons:
- No growth potential; fixed payout
- Loss of liquidity; principal is converted to income
- Inflation risk unless a cost-of-living rider is added (extra cost)
Typical Use Cases
|
Situation |
FIA |
SPIA |
|
Younger retiree, wants growth and income later |
✔ Deferred income with index-linked growth |
❌ Not suitable (no growth, starts immediately) |
|
Retiree wanting guaranteed immediate cash flow |
❌ Payments not immediate |
✔ Lifetime income to cover living expenses |
|
HNW retiree seeking tax deferral and optional income rider |
✔ Can accumulate large balance tax-deferred |
❌ Usually doesn’t provide flexibility for later growth |
|
Protect against longevity risk |
✔ If lifetime income rider added |
✔ Naturally hedges longevity risk |
Summary
|
Aspect |
FIA |
SPIA |
|
Growth Potential |
Moderate (linked to index) |
None (fixed) |
|
Guaranteed Income |
Optional; deferred |
Immediate; guaranteed |
|
Liquidity |
Low (surrender penalties) |
Very low; payments cannot be lump sum |
|
Risk |
Low–moderate (market upside, principal protected) |
Very low (income guaranteed, no market exposure) |
|
Best For |
Tax-deferred growth, optional future income |
Immediate, predictable lifetime income, replacing paycheck |
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment